How to unlock rewards in RDR 2
Rewards will not be available immediately. It must take at least 7 hours from the start of the game. After the stranger's marker appears in the Valentine Sheriff's office, access to the rewards will be opened.
At the Sheriff's office, Arthur will need to agree to a mission, which is to catch the killer and return him to prison. Morgan will find the culprit North of Valentine, near the river. He will sit under an overhanging rock, next to the fire.
Capture him alive by throwing a lasso at him. Then press the right trigger to pull your captive towards you. Get off the horse, still holding the lasso with the left button. Approach the prisoner by pressing Circle / B. Now put the wanted man on the back of your horse and take them to the Sheriff's office in Valentine. You will be paid an amount of $ 50. The mission will be completed.
He must be taken alive. To do this, you will need to use a lasso. After the man is caught, all Arthur has to do is throw him over the horse and take him to the Sheriff's office. In return, he will receive $ 50.
After that, the rewards will be available. To find out about them, you will need to find a poster hanging in one of the cities. They are mostly found in Valentine and Strawberry.
The level of honor and the amount of reward will be higher if you manage to catch and deliver the criminal alive. But this is not always possible, it all depends on the complexity of the quest to catch.